Your nonprofit needs a skilled, dedicated team to advance its mission. Use these onboarding best practices to set your new hires up for lasting success.

By Debbie Willis

Every new employee brings passion, talent, and a fresh perspective to your nonprofit. However, recruiting and retaining these essential team members is not always easy. In fact, 60% of nonprofit leaders report experiencing staff-related concerns—whether that’s a lack of staff capacity or losing staff because they cannot provide competitive pay and benefits.

Your nonprofit’s new hires and long-time employees are all dedicated to making the world a better place, but they need an environment that allows them to flourish. So, how do you foster this kind of environment?

Building the foundation your employees need to thrive begins with onboarding. Just as you start the year strong with clear goals and plans, help new hires step into their roles with clear expectations, training, and support.

Let’s walk through five best practices to boost morale, productivity, and retention through your employee onboarding process.

1. Use a learning management system.

It’s easy to assume that only corporations and large nonprofits operating in multiple locations need a learning management system (LMS) to help train and onboard employees. However, even small nonprofits—especially those with hybrid or remote employees—can benefit from investing in an LMS.

With a dedicated learning platform, you can create structured onboarding pathways, provide more convenient access to resources (sometimes even in multiple languages), and engage new hires in an online learning community. According to TopClass’s LMS for nonprofits guide, your platform should come with these essential features:

Alt Text: The top features nonprofits need in an LMS, as explained in more detail below

• Branded Learning Dashboard: Each new hire can monitor their individual onboarding progress and view achievements on a personalized dashboard branded to your nonprofit.
• Various Types of Content: To design a more engaging onboarding experience, you can incorporate various types of content, from interactive videos to timed assessments.
• Collaborative Learning: Turn onboarding from a solo journey into a social experience through discussion forums, leaderboards, and cohort-based learning sessions.
• Secure Payment Processing: Beyond onboarding, your nonprofit can offer learning programs to individuals and partner organizations for a fee. Many LMS platforms facilitate this by allowing you to sell courses, create coupons, and set up discounts.
• Assessment Tools: Throughout onboarding, add mini-assessments with true-false, multiple-choice, and free-form questions to ensure your new employees are well-prepared and identify any knowledge gaps to address.
• Integrations: Your LMS should integrate with popular tools, including HR systems and CRMs like Salesforce, to help you create a seamless onboarding process for the entire team.
• Advanced Reporting: Track employee onboarding progress, assessment results, and certification completion to provide each new hire with the appropriate support, recognition, and follow-up.

Plus, you can use your nonprofit’s LMS to streamline many other processes and activities, including upskilling employees, onboarding volunteers, and educating board members.

2. Create a clear, detailed onboarding checklist.

You need to get your new employees up and running promptly so they can start contributing to your mission-centric initiatives. To minimize confusion and help new hires prepare for what’s ahead, provide them with a step-by-step onboarding checklist to follow. Whether this is a simple Google Doc or an automated path in your LMS, your checklist should cover basic activities and tasks such as:

• Learn about the nonprofit’s mission, values, programs, and leadership.
• Review workplace policies, including communication and paid time off (PTO).
• Attend a virtual or in-person tour of the facility.
• Set up an email, software access, and a workstation.
• Complete compliance and technology training.
• Share feedback in an onboarding survey.

Remember, the purpose of onboarding is to help employees feel comfortable and confident in joining your nonprofit’s team. Rather than generally familiarizing new hires with your organization, encourage them to start engaging deeply with your mission. Take opportunities to share real stories about your impact and provide access to nonprofit webinars and other resources that they can use to immerse themselves in your work.

3. Assign a mentor or buddy to new hires.

Life at a nonprofit can be very fast-paced. Create a mentorship or buddy program to help your new hires find a sense of belonging and avoid feeling overwhelmed when they start. By pairing each new employee with a more experienced team member, you provide them with individualized encouragement and support through onboarding and beyond.

When pairing mentors or buddies with new hires:

• Be thoughtful about each match. Survey new employees about their learning preferences, communication styles, career goals, and interests. Use these insights to assign a mentor or buddy who will provide the most relevant support for each new hire—for example, you might pair a new social media manager with the digital marketing manager to learn more about brand voice and storytelling techniques.
• Schedule regular check-ins. Provide formal and informal opportunities for new hires to connect with their mentor or buddy. You might use your LMS to arrange structured check-ins with relevant discussion prompts. At the same time, encourage pairings to meet for casual coffee chats to delve into specific questions the new employee may have about workplace expectations or guidelines, such as your fiscal policies.
• Offer recognition and incentives. Inspire new hire mentors and buddies to put in their best effort by giving them a shout out in newsletters or “Mentor of the Month” programs. You can even award their time and dedication with a small gift card, a branded t-shirt, or additional PTO.

Incorporate questions related to your mentorship or buddy program into your onboarding survey to collect feedback and learn how to improve your pairings going forward.

4. Focus on building social connections.

During onboarding, your nonprofit should focus beyond simply getting employees up to speed in their roles. Go deeper to help new hires find a sense of camaraderie and closeness in their new workplace. After all, recent Gallup research indicates that employees with a best friend at work are much more productive and less likely to leave their organization.

Of course, nurturing these friendships requires more than simply telling your employees to bond. Building relationships with donors is a year-round effort, and the same goes for your employees. Start early by incorporating some of these social ideas into your onboarding process:

• Invite new hires to share interesting facts about themselves on internal communication channels.
• Assign rotating lunch or coffee pairings with a new team member each week.
• Break the ice with a team storytelling session in which everyone shares why they’re passionate about your cause.
• Set up a virtual or in-person scavenger hunt for items related to your nonprofit’s work.

By adding more opportunities for new hires to laugh and learn during onboarding, you can make them feel welcome both in their roles and in your organization’s community as a whole.

5. Check in and provide feedback frequently.

Develop trust and engagement early by regularly checking in with new employees and providing feedback on their progress. For example, during the first week of onboarding, managers could meet with new hires for 15 minutes every day to answer questions. Then, these check-ins can turn into weekly one-on-one meetings to discuss expectations, performance, and challenges.

Establish a culture of gratitude at your nonprofit by frequently expressing appreciation to donors and employees—including new hires. Consider these thoughtful ideas for making your new employees feel valued:

• Spotlight them in email newsletters and social media posts, along with their skills and hobbies.
• Gift them branded apparel, notebooks, water bottles, etc.
• Celebrate onboarding completion with a certificate or badge.

Additionally, empower your nonprofit’s team to spread positivity and appreciation through peer-to-peer recognition. For example, eCardWidget recommends designing employee recognition eCards that team members can personalize and send to their peers for a job well done or other career milestones.

---

Improving your onboarding process, whether through implementing an LMS or launching a mentorship program, will create lasting benefits throughout each new employee’s experience at your nonprofit. 

Start small, focusing on the main improvement areas you identify from onboarding survey responses, and be transparent about the changes you make along the way. Before long, you’ll have an onboarding process that fuels engagement, connection, and loyalty.

Debbie Willis is the VP of Global Marketing at ASI, with over 20 years of marketing experience in the association and non-profit technology space. Passionate about all things MarTech, Debbie has led countless website, SEO, content, email, paid ad, and social media marketing strategies and campaigns. Debbie loves creating meaningful content to engage and empower association and non-profit audiences.

Debbie received a Bachelor of Business Administration in Marketing Information Systems from James Madison University and a Master of Business Administration in Marketing from George Washington University. Debbie is a member of Sigma Sigma Sigma sorority and American Society of Association Executives, and dabbles in photography.